Sometimes an employer cannot meet a Cal/OSHA standard on the date it takes effect, or has a method that protects workers as well as the standard does but does not match its exact wording. California law provides a formal route for both situations: the variance. A variance is not a citation appeal or an informal exemption. It is a written order, issued after notice to employees, that lets an employer depart from a specific Title 8 requirement under stated conditions.
Two Kinds of Variance, Two Decision Makers
Different bodies decide each kind.
- Temporary variances are governed by Labor Code §§6450 through 6457, which make up Chapter 5, Temporary Variances. The employer applies to the Division of Occupational Safety and Health under Labor Code §6450, and the Division grants or denies the order.
- Permanent variances are governed by Labor Code §143. The employer applies to the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board, and the Board decides.
The Standards Board also hears appeals from the Division’s temporary variance decisions. Its procedural rules are in Title 8, Chapter 3.5, Subchapter 1, §§401 through 428.
Temporary Variances Under Labor Code §6450
A temporary variance answers one problem: the employer cannot comply with a standard by its effective date. Under §6450, the employer must establish three things:
- It is unable to comply by the effective date because of unavailable personnel, materials, or equipment, or because necessary construction or alteration cannot be completed in time.
- It is taking all available steps to safeguard employees against the hazards the standard covers.
- It has an effective program for coming into compliance as quickly as practicable.
The order prescribes the practices the employer must use and states the compliance program in detail. It remains in effect for no longer than the time needed to comply or one year, whichever is shorter. It may be renewed no more than twice, each renewal application must be filed before the order expires, and no single renewal may exceed 180 days.
Labor Code §6451 lists what the application must contain:
- The standard, or portion of it, from which the variance is sought (§6451(a))
- A statement, supported by qualified persons with firsthand knowledge, that the employer cannot comply, with detailed reasons (§6451(b))
- The steps taken and to be taken to protect employees, with specific dates (§6451(c))
- When the employer expects to comply and the steps toward compliance, with dates (§6451(d))
- A certification that employees were informed, through their authorized representative and a posted summary, of the application and their right to petition the Division for a hearing (§6451(e))
Because a temporary order requires notice to employees and an opportunity for a hearing, it takes time. Section 6450 addresses the gap. The Division may issue one interim order where the workplace will be safe for employees pending the hearing. There is one interim order, not a series, and the safety showing comes first.
Permanent Variances Under Labor Code §143
A permanent variance is for an employer whose alternative protects employees at least as well as the standard. Under §143(a), any employer may apply to the Standards Board for a permanent variance from a standard, order, or special order, or a portion of one, on a showing of an alternative program, method, practice, means, device, or process that provides equal or superior safety for employees.
Section 143(b) sets the decision standard. The Board issues the variance only if it determines on the record, after an investigation where appropriate and a hearing, that the proponent has shown by a preponderance of the evidence that its conditions, practices, means, methods, operations, or processes will be as safe and healthful for employees as compliance with the standard. Under §143(d), a permanent variance may be modified or revoked at any time on application by the employer, employees, or the Division, or on the Board’s own motion.
The application itself is governed by Title 8 §411. It is filed in writing with the Standards Board under penalty of perjury and must include:
- The employer’s name and address and each place of employment involved
- A description of the alternative conditions, practices, or processes, and a statement showing how they provide equal or superior safety and health
- A certification that the employer will comply with the notification and posting rules in §§411.2 and 411.3
- The specific Title 8 regulation, including subsections, from which the variance is sought
- Whether an appeal on the same standard is filed or pending with the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board, with the docket number
- A witness and hearing-time estimate, and copies of any illustrative materials
Under §411.1, a defective application is not docketed. The employer is told what is wrong, and if the defects are not corrected within 60 days, the application is automatically denied. A denial on that ground does not bar a new application. When I review a variance request before filing, the equal-or-superior statement is where most drafts are weakest. It has to show protection, not convenience.
Notice to Employees and Party Status
Employees have a defined role in variance proceedings. Under §411.3(a), the employer must post, at the places where employee notices are customarily posted:
- The docketed application or appeal, or a summary stating where a full copy can be examined, immediately after notice of docketing (§411.3(a)(1))
- A notice of the affected employees’ right to party status, to inspect and copy pleadings, and to petition the Board for a hearing (§411.3(a)(2))
- The notice of hearing, immediately on receipt (§411.3(a)(3))
Section 411.3(b) requires copies to go immediately to any authorized employee representative, and §411.3(c) requires the posting to remain until the hearing begins or the matter is resolved. Under §406(a), affected employees or their authorized representative may elect party status any time before the hearing begins. Under §406(b), the Division is a party to every proceeding, and under §415 the Board refers each docketed application and appeal to the Division for an evaluation report.
Hearings, Decisions, and Rehearing
Under §426(a), the hearing may be held before the Board, a hearing panel, or a hearing officer. A panel or hearing officer prepares a proposed decision, which the Board may adopt. If it does not, §426(c) allows the Board to decide the case on the record, with or without additional evidence, or refer it back to a panel or hearing officer. A party may petition for rehearing within 20 days after service of the decision, limited to three grounds in §427(a): the Board acted without or in excess of its powers, the decision is not supported by substantial evidence, or it is contrary to law.
Under §428(a), a permanent variance applies only to the employer it was issued to and only at the listed locations, and it does not transfer when the business transfers to another entity. Adding a site or changing terms requires a modification under §428(b).
Appealing a Temporary Variance Decision
An employer or other person adversely affected by the Division’s grant or denial of a temporary variance may appeal to the Standards Board under Labor Code §6455 within 15 working days of receiving notice of the decision. The Board may extend it for good cause. Under Title 8 §412(b), the appeal must be in writing and state the grounds. An appeal that omits the grounds may be amended within 15 days of the Board’s notice under §412.1, or it is dismissed. Under Labor Code §6457, the Board’s written decision is final except for rehearing or judicial review, and under §6456 it binds the Director and the Division as to the parties.
How a Variance Differs From a Citation Appeal
A citation appeal goes to a different body, the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board, under Labor Code §6600. It challenges what the Division has already alleged: the violation, the abatement period, the proposed penalty, or the reasonableness of required abatement changes. It must be filed within 15 working days of receipt of the citation.
A variance goes to the Division or the Standards Board and asks for an order governing how the employer will operate. Section 411 asks whether an Appeals Board appeal on the same standard is pending, so the two can run side by side, but one does not replace the other. Nothing in the variance rules extends the §6600 filing period, so an employer who files only a variance request after receiving a citation risks losing the right to contest it. For citation timing, see Cal/OSHA appeal deadlines.
What to Do This Week
- Decide which problem you have: a compliance date you cannot meet, or an alternative method that protects as well as the standard.
- Identify the exact Title 8 section and subsection you would vary from.
- If a citation is open on the same standard, calendar the §6600 appeal deadline now.
- Draft the employee notice and identify every posting location and employee representative.
If you are weighing a variance or responding to a citation on the same standard, see my Cal/OSHA citation defense service, request a consultation, or call (626) 546-9384.