Service area: Available in California, Nevada, Arizona, Oregon, Washington, Idaho, Montana, Utah, Wyoming, Colorado, New Mexico, North Dakota, South Dakota, Texas, Oklahoma, Louisiana, Nebraska, Alabama, Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Tennessee, Vermont, Virginia, West Virginia and Wisconsin.
McNeil Safety Consulting represents employers in OSHA citation matters across the lower 48 states, under State Plan programs and under federal OSHA. Call (626) 546-9384.
Scope of Work
- Inspection response — opening conference, document production, interview coordination, walkaround representation.
- Pre-citation response — written response to a Cal/OSHA Form 1AY or an equivalent state or federal document demand before citations issue.
- Notice of contest and appeal preparation — filing within the jurisdiction’s deadline, affirmative defenses, docket management.
- Informal conference representation — penalty reduction, classification challenges, abatement dates.
- Classification challenges — serious, willful, repeat and accident-related designations.
- Abatement and certification — corrective action documentation and abatement certification packages.
- Discovery support — subpoenas duces tecum, document demands, motions to compel.
- Settlement negotiation — with the Division or the Area Office.
Which Agency Has Your Site
Twenty-two states run OSHA-approved State Plans covering private-sector employers. In the remaining states federal OSHA has jurisdiction. The deadline to contest a citation is not the same everywhere, and it is jurisdictional.
| State | Agency | Deadline to contest |
|---|---|---|
| California | Cal/OSHA — State Plan | 15 working days from receipt |
| Arizona | ADOSH — State Plan | 15 working days from receipt |
| Nevada | Nevada OSHA — State Plan | 30 calendar days from receipt |
| New Mexico | NM OHSB — State Plan | 15 working days from receipt |
| Oregon | Oregon OSHA — State Plan | 30 days from receipt |
| Utah | UOSH — State Plan | 30 days from receipt |
| Washington | DOSH, L&I — State Plan | 15 working days from receipt |
| Wyoming | Wyoming OSHA — State Plan | 15 working days from receipt |
| Colorado | Federal OSHA | 15 working days from receipt |
| Idaho | Federal OSHA | 15 working days from receipt |
| Montana | Federal OSHA | 15 working days from receipt |
| North Dakota | Federal OSHA | 15 working days from receipt |
| South Dakota | Federal OSHA | 15 working days from receipt |
Each state page sets out the agency, the statute, the body that hears the contest and where the filing goes. Start at the service area.
Federal OSHA Procedure
- Notice of contest — 15 working days from receipt of the notice of proposed penalty, postmarked within that period. 29 U.S.C. §659(a); 29 CFR §1903.17(a).
- Filed with — the OSHA Area Director for the area in which the citation was issued.
- Heard by — the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission.
- Effect of missing it — the citation and penalty become a final order of the Commission and are not subject to review by any court or agency.
California Procedure
- Appeal — 15 working days from receipt. Labor Code §6600; 8 CCR §359(d).
- Filed with — the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board.
- Non-attorney representation — permitted under 8 CCR §378(a). You do not need an attorney to appeal.
- Serious injury, illness or death — report immediately, and in no event more than 8 hours after the employer knows or should have known. Labor Code §6409.1(b).
- Multi-employer worksites — 8 CCR §336.10 allows citation of the controlling, creating, exposing or correcting employer.
See representative case studies, the Cal/OSHA citations guide, the appeal deadlines guide and the district office directory.
What an OSHA Citation Defense Consultant Does
An OSHA citation defense consultant is a safety professional, not a lawyer, who works the technical side of a contested citation: whether the cited standard actually applies, whether the condition existed as the inspector described it, whether the classification holds, and whether the abatement date and the required changes are reasonable. Those are the questions most citations turn on, and they are answered with exposure data, program records and the physical conditions on site rather than with legal argument alone.
Before the California Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board a party may appear through a representative who is not required to be an attorney (8 CCR §378(a)). Before the federal Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission the same is true under 29 CFR 2200.22. McNeil Safety Consulting works either as the designated representative or alongside the employer’s counsel.
What happens in the 15 working days
- Read the citation, the proposed penalty and any document request, and fix the appeal deadline from the date of receipt.
- Request the inspection file and compare the inspector’s notes, photographs and sampling with what was actually on site.
- Walk the site, document the cited conditions as they stand now, and preserve the evidence before it changes.
- Pull the records the Division will ask for first: the Injury and Illness Prevention Program under 8 CCR §3203, training records, inspections and prior abatement.
- Identify the appeal grounds for each item: existence of the violation, classification, abatement date, required changes and penalty amount.
- Prepare for the informal conference and the Appeals Board, and document abatement so the employer is not exposed to a failure-to-abate citation while the appeal runs.
Why employers hire a consultant for citation defense
Serious classifications carry a rebuttable presumption under Labor Code §6432, and the rebuttal is factual: what the employer knew, what a reasonable employer would have done, and how fast the hazard was corrected. That record is built by someone who can read a sampling report, a ventilation drawing or a training matrix and explain it to the Board. Every matter is handled personally by Michael Karl McNeil, REP, RIH, EPP, QSD, a Former Fire Battalion Chief who has been deposed more than 60 times. Work is never subcontracted.
McNeil Safety Consulting is not a law firm. Where a matter carries criminal exposure, parallel civil litigation or a novel legal question, counsel belongs in it, and we work with counsel. Deadlines and representation rules for each state are set out on the OSHA citation appeal deadlines by state page, and Cal/OSHA classifications and penalties are explained in the Cal/OSHA citations guide. Where a citation follows an injury that is already in litigation, see OSHA expert witness and litigation support.
Questions
Do I need a lawyer to contest a citation?
In California, no. 8 CCR §378(a) allows a non-attorney representative before the Appeals Board. Other jurisdictions differ, and a contested federal case before the Review Commission that proceeds under conventional rules is usually handled with counsel. McNeil Safety Consulting works both as the designated representative and alongside an employer’s counsel.
What happens if the deadline passes?
The citation, the penalty and the abatement dates become a final order. Under federal law the final order is not subject to review by any court or agency. Relief after the fact is limited and discretionary.
Is the Nevada deadline really different?
Yes. NRS 618.475(1) gives 30 calendar days from receipt, not the 15 working days used federally and in most State Plan states. Oregon and Utah also run 30 days rather than 15 working days.
Can you take a case before citations issue?
Yes, and that is usually the better point to bring someone in. Document demands, interview scheduling and the employer’s written response shape what gets alleged. Federal OSHA has six months from the occurrence of a violation to issue a citation; California runs the same six-month period under Labor Code §6317.
What is the difference between an OSHA citation defense consultant and an OSHA defense attorney?
A consultant works the technical merits of each citation item, the exposure evidence, the employer’s programs and the abatement. An attorney handles legal strategy, privilege, criminal exposure and related litigation. In California and before the federal Review Commission a non-attorney may represent the employer, so many citations are contested with a consultant alone, and larger matters are handled by both together.
Can a citation defense consultant represent us at the informal conference and the appeal?
Yes, in California under 8 CCR §378(a) and in the federal OSHA states under 29 CFR 2200.22. McNeil Safety Consulting provides representation in California, Nevada, Oregon, New Mexico and Wyoming and in the federal OSHA states it serves. In Washington, Utah and Arizona the work is consulting, industrial hygiene and expert support, with the appearance left to counsel.
When should we call about a citation?
As soon as it arrives. In California and under federal OSHA the appeal must be filed within 15 working days of receipt; Oregon and Utah allow 30 days. The informal conference does not stop that clock, and evidence on site changes quickly. Call (626) 546-9384.
Contact
McNeil Safety Consulting, 9163 Arcadia Ave, San Gabriel, CA 91775. (626) 546-9384 · mike@mcneilsafetyconsulting.com
McNeil Safety Consulting is not a law firm and does not provide legal advice.
Outside California: the federal rules that apply
California is our primary service area, so this page cites Cal/OSHA and Title 8. In the other states we serve, the same work is done under the federal rules below, or under the state’s own OSHA-approved plan where one exists. See the state pages for each state.
- Federal OSHA — a notice of contest must be postmarked within 15 working days of receipt of the notice of proposed penalty (29 U.S.C. 659(a); 29 CFR 1903.17(a)), and an employer may appear before the Occupational Safety and Health Review Commission through a non-attorney representative (29 CFR 2200.22(a)).
- CDC / NIOSH — NIOSH exposure data and criteria documents, used to test whether a cited health hazard was recognized.
- EPA — where the same event also drew an environmental notice, the two matters are coordinated.
States We Serve
McNeil Safety Consulting provides this service to clients in the following states:
- California
- Nevada
- Arizona
- Oregon
- Washington
- Idaho
- Montana
- Utah
- Wyoming
- Colorado
- New Mexico
- North Dakota
- South Dakota
- Texas
- Oklahoma
- Louisiana
- Nebraska
- Alabama
- Arkansas
- Connecticut
- Delaware
- Florida
- Georgia
- Illinois
- Indiana
- Iowa
- Kansas
- Kentucky
- Maine
- Maryland
- Massachusetts
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- Mississippi
- Missouri
- New Hampshire
- New Jersey
- New York
- North Carolina
- Ohio
- Pennsylvania
- Rhode Island
- South Carolina
- Tennessee
- Vermont
- Virginia
- West Virginia
- Wisconsin
To confirm coverage for your site, call (626) 546-9384.
