Process Safety Management in California: Section 5189

By Michael Karl McNeil, REP, RIH, EPP, QSD

California’s process safety management rule is Title 8, Section 5189, “Process Safety Management of Acutely Hazardous Materials.” It shares most of its structure with federal 29 CFR 1910.119, but it has its own IIPP provision and no compliance-audit subsection.

Who Section 5189 Applies To

Subsection (a) states the purpose: preventing or minimizing the consequences of catastrophic releases of toxic, reactive, flammable, or explosive chemicals in petroleum refineries, chemical plants, and other facilities. Subsection (b)(1) sets coverage. A process is covered if it involves an acutely hazardous material at or above the threshold quantity listed in Appendix A, or if it involves a Category 1 flammable gas or a flammable liquid with a flashpoint below 100 degrees F on site in one location in a quantity of 10,000 pounds or more.

The exceptions in (b)(1) include:

  • Flammable liquids with a flashpoint below 100 degrees F stored in atmospheric tanks or transferred, kept below their normal boiling point without the benefit of chilling or refrigeration.
  • Hydrocarbon fuels used solely for workplace consumption as a fuel, such as propane for comfort heating, unless the fuel is part of a process containing another covered acutely hazardous material.
  • Retail facilities, oil or gas well drilling or servicing operations, and normally unoccupied remote facilities.

Under subsection (c), a “process” includes use, storage, manufacturing, handling, or on-site movement, and interconnected or nearby vessels that could be involved in one release count as a single process. A “major accident” is a fire, explosion, or release of a covered material resulting in a death or a serious injury as defined in Labor Code §6302.

Section 5189.1 Is a Separate Rule for Refineries

Section 5189.1, “Process Safety Management for Petroleum Refineries,” applies to processes in petroleum refineries, defined by reference to NAICS Code 324110. For those processes, §5189.1(b) states that it supersedes §5189. This post covers §5189 only.

Information and Hazard Analysis

Process safety information, §5189(d). The written information must be compiled before the process hazard analysis is conducted, and the employer must allow employee participation in preparing it. It covers three categories:

  • Hazards of the materials (d)(1): toxicity information, permissible exposure limits as listed in §5155, physical, corrosivity, thermal and chemical stability, and reactivity data, and the hazardous effects of incompatible mixtures that could foreseeably occur.
  • Technology of the process (d)(2): a block or simplified process flow diagram, process chemistry, maximum intended inventory, safe upper and lower limits, and the consequences of deviations.
  • Equipment (d)(3): materials of construction, piping and instrument diagrams, electrical classification, relief and ventilation design, design codes, material and energy balances for processes built after September 1, 1992, and safety systems.

Process hazard analysis, §5189(e). The employer must perform a hazard analysis appropriate to the complexity of the process, set and document a priority order, and use at least one of the listed methods, such as What-If, HAZOP, or FMEA (e)(1). The analysis must address the hazards of the process, engineering and administrative controls and their interrelationships, the consequences of failure of those controls, facility siting, human factors, a qualitative evaluation of possible safety and health effects on employees, and previous incidents with a likely potential for catastrophic consequences (e)(2).

The team requirements are in (e)(3)(A): expertise in engineering and process operations, at least one employee with experience and knowledge specific to the process, and one member knowledgeable in the methodology used. Under (e)(4), findings must be addressed promptly under a documented system with a written completion schedule. Under (e)(5), the analysis must be updated and revalidated at least every five years by a team meeting (e)(3). Subsection (e)(6) requires the analyses, updates, and documented resolutions to be kept for each process.

Procedures, Training, and Contractors

Operating procedures, §5189(f). Written procedures must cover each operating phase, operating limits, and safety and health considerations (f)(1). They must be readily accessible to employees who work in or near the process (f)(2) and reviewed as often as necessary to reflect current practice and changes to chemicals, technology, equipment, and facilities (f)(3). Subsection (f)(4) requires safe work practices, including for opening process equipment and controlling entry by support personnel.

Training, §5189(g). Each employee operating or maintaining a process, and each employee before working in a newly assigned process, must be trained in an overview of the process and its operating procedures, with emphasis on the hazards and safe practices for that employee’s tasks (g)(1). Refresher training is required at least every three years, and more often if necessary (g)(2). Records must show the employee, the date, and the trainer’s signature (g)(3).

Contractors, §5189(h). The host employer must inform contractors of known fire, explosion, and toxic release hazards (h)(1), explain the emergency action plan (h)(2), evaluate safety programs when selecting contractors (h)(5) and performance afterward (h)(6), and obtain the contractor’s injury and illness log (h)(7).

Change, Startup, and Equipment Integrity

Pre-startup safety review, §5189(i). A review is required for new facilities and for modified facilities when the modification necessitates a change in the process safety information (i)(1). Before acutely hazardous materials are introduced, it must confirm that construction and equipment match design specifications, that procedures are in place and adequate, that a hazard analysis has been performed for new facilities with recommendations resolved or implemented, that modified facilities meet the management-of-change requirements, and that training is complete (i)(2).

Mechanical integrity, §5189(j). Written procedures must include a means for employees to report faulty equipment (j)(1). Inspections and tests must be performed on process equipment, follow recognized and generally accepted good engineering practice, and occur at a frequency consistent with manufacturer recommendations and prior operating experience (j)(2). Each inspection must be documented with the date, the person who performed it, and an identifier for the equipment. Deficiencies must be corrected (j)(3), and quality assurance applies to construction and parts (j)(4).

Hot work, §5189(k). A written procedure is required, and a hot work permit must document that the fire prevention requirements of §§4848 and 6777 are implemented, along with the authorized dates and the equipment involved.

Management of change, §5189(l). Written procedures must cover changes to process chemicals, technology, equipment, and facilities, other than replacement in kind (l)(1). Procedures must address the technical basis, safety and health impact, operating procedure changes, time period, and authorization (l)(2). Affected employees must be informed and trained before startup (l)(3), and process safety information and operating procedures must be updated where affected (l)(4) and (l)(5). In the programs I review, a gap I find repeatedly is a change handled under MOC whose operating procedure was never revised.

Incidents, Emergencies, IIPP, and Participation

Incident investigation, §5189(m). The employer needs a written procedure for promptly reporting and investigating each incident that resulted in, or could reasonably have resulted in, a major accident (m)(1). Investigations must be initiated no later than 48 hours following the incident (m)(2). The team must include someone knowledgeable in the process and, where contract work was involved, a contract employee (m)(3). The report must include the incident date, the date the investigation began, a description, contributing factors, and recommendations (m)(4). It must be reviewed with affected personnel (m)(5), its findings resolved (m)(6), and kept for five years (m)(7).

Emergency planning, §5189(n). The employer must establish and implement an emergency action plan under §3220. A business plan prepared under the Health and Safety Code may be used if it meets the requirements of (n). My emergency response planning page covers those plans.

IIPP, §5189(o). Subsection (o)(1) requires the scheduled and periodic inspections called for by §3203(a)(4) to be performed by at least one person knowledgeable in the process.

Employee participation, §5189(p). The employer must have a written plan of action for consulting employees and their representatives on the development and conduct of the PSM elements (p)(1), and must give them access to the information the section requires, without regard to possible trade secret status (p)(2). The employer may require a confidentiality agreement under §5194.

Compliance Audits: California Versus Federal

The federal standard requires a certified compliance audit at least every three years at 29 CFR 1910.119(o)(1), conducted by at least one person knowledgeable in the process, with the two most recent reports retained under (o)(5). Section 5189 as currently published contains no compliance-audit subsection; its subsection (o) is the IIPP provision described above. A periodic audit of every element is still good practice under §5189, though not a stated requirement. When I audit a PSM program, elements (d) through (p) are my checklist.

What to Do This Week

  1. Compare on-site quantities against the current Appendix A and the 10,000-pound flammable threshold in §5189(b)(1).
  2. Pull the date of each process hazard analysis and schedule any revalidation coming due under the five-year interval in (e)(5).
  3. Check refresher training dates against the three-year interval in (g)(2).
  4. Confirm every incident investigation in the last five years began within 48 hours and has documented resolution of its recommendations.
  5. Locate your written employee participation plan under (p)(1).

Program reviews, hazard analysis facilitation, and gap assessments are part of my PSM compliance service. To request a consultation, call (626) 546-9384.

Need help with a Cal/OSHA matter?

McNeil Safety Consulting provides Cal/OSHA citation defense, industrial hygiene, safety plan writing, and expert witness services throughout California. Call (626) 546-9384 or request a consultation.