Laboratory Chemical Hygiene Plan Requirements Under Title 8 Section 5191

By Michael Karl McNeil, REP, RIH, EPP, QSD

The laboratory Chemical Hygiene Plans I am asked to review tend to share the same problems. The plan came from a template, the Chemical Hygiene Officer named on the cover has changed jobs, and nobody can say when the plan was last evaluated. Title 8, Section 5191, Occupational Exposure to Hazardous Chemicals in Laboratories, states what the written plan has to contain and how often it has to be reviewed. This article covers scope, the required plan elements, the Chemical Hygiene Officer, exposure determination, training, medical consultation, particularly hazardous substances and the annual review.

When Section 5191 Applies

Section 5191(a)(1) applies to all employers engaged in the laboratory use of hazardous chemicals. Section 5191(b) defines “laboratory use of hazardous chemicals” as handling or use in which all four of these conditions are met:

  1. Chemical manipulations are carried out on a laboratory scale.
  2. Multiple chemical procedures or chemicals are used.
  3. The procedures are not part of a production process and do not in any way simulate one.
  4. Protective laboratory practices and equipment are available and in common use to minimize the potential for employee exposure.

“Laboratory scale” means work in which the containers used for reactions, transfers and other handling are designed to be easily and safely manipulated by one person. The definition excludes workplaces whose function is to produce commercial quantities of materials.

Under Section 5191(a)(3)(A), a use that does not meet the definition of laboratory use falls under the other relevant Title 8 regulations, even if it takes place in a laboratory. Under Section 5191(a)(3)(B), laboratory uses with no potential for employee exposure are outside the section. The text gives dip-and-read test strips and commercially prepared kits as examples.

Where the section applies, subsection (a)(2) states that it supersedes, for laboratories, Section 5190 and the Article 110 regulated carcinogen standards, with listed exceptions. Exposure limits still apply, and Section 5217, the formaldehyde standard, applies to anatomy, histology and pathology laboratories. Under Section 5191(k)(2), subsection (a)(2) does not take effect until the employer has developed and implemented a written Chemical Hygiene Plan.

Required Elements of the Written Plan

Section 5191(e)(1) requires the employer to develop and carry out a written Chemical Hygiene Plan that is capable of protecting employees from the health hazards of the chemicals in that laboratory and of keeping exposures below the limits referenced in Section 5191(c). It must be readily available to employees, employee representatives and, on request, the Chief of the Division of Occupational Safety and Health.

Section 5191(e)(3) lists eight elements and says the plan must indicate the specific measures the employer will take:

  • Standard operating procedures for safety and health when laboratory work involves hazardous chemicals, subsection (e)(3)(A).
  • Control criteria for engineering controls, personal protective equipment and hygiene practices, with particular attention to chemicals known to be extremely hazardous, subsection (e)(3)(B).
  • Fume hoods and protective equipment. Hoods must comply with Section 5154.1, and the plan must state specific measures to keep protective equipment performing, subsection (e)(3)(C).
  • Information and training under subsection (f), subsection (e)(3)(D).
  • Prior approval. The circumstances in which an operation, procedure or activity needs approval from the employer or the employer’s designee before it starts, subsection (e)(3)(E).
  • Medical consultation and examinations under subsection (g), subsection (e)(3)(F).
  • Responsible personnel, including a Chemical Hygiene Officer and, if appropriate, a Chemical Hygiene Committee, subsection (e)(3)(G).
  • Additional protection for work with particularly hazardous substances, subsection (e)(3)(H).

The fume hood element pulls in Section 5154.1. Section 5154.1(c)(1) calls for an average face velocity of at least 100 feet per minute with a minimum of 70 feet per minute at any point. Section 5154.1(e)(3) requires a quantitative airflow monitor on the hood and a qualitative airflow demonstration at installation, annually (every two years where a calibration and maintenance program covers the monitor), after repairs or renovations, and after large equipment is added. Where I see plans fall short is a sentence saying hoods will be maintained, with nothing on who tests them, by what method and when.

The Chemical Hygiene Officer

Section 5191(b) defines the Chemical Hygiene Officer as an employee, designated by the employer, who is qualified by training or experience to provide technical guidance in developing and implementing the plan. The definition is not intended to limit the position description or job classification the person holds.

The definition describes an employee. The plan should name a person inside the organization who holds the role and has the authority to act on it. Check that name against the current staff list.

Exposure Determination

Section 5191(c) requires that laboratory employees’ exposures to Cal/OSHA regulated substances not exceed the exposure limits in the General Industry Safety Orders. Section 5191(d) sets the monitoring rule:

  • Initial monitoring. The employer must measure exposure to any substance regulated by a standard that requires monitoring if there is reason to believe exposure exceeds the action level, or the exposure limit where no action level exists. The person supervising, directing or evaluating the monitoring must be competent in industrial hygiene practice, subsection (d)(1).
  • Periodic monitoring. If initial monitoring shows exposure over that level, the employer must immediately comply with the monitoring provisions of the relevant regulation, subsection (d)(2).
  • Notification. Within 15 working days after receiving results, the employer must notify the employee in writing, individually or by posting in a location accessible to employees, subsection (d)(4).

The trigger is “reason to believe.” I write that judgment down for each regulated substance in the inventory.

Training and Medical Consultation

Section 5191(f)(2) requires information and training at initial assignment to a work area where hazardous chemicals are present and before assignments involving new exposure situations. Subsection (f)(3) lists what employees must be informed of: the contents of Section 5191 and its appendices, the location of the Chemical Hygiene Plan, applicable exposure limits, signs and symptoms of exposure, and the location of reference material including Safety Data Sheets. Subsection (f)(4) requires training on how to detect the presence or release of a hazardous chemical, the physical and health hazards in the work area, protective measures including emergency procedures, and the applicable details of the written plan.

Section 5191(g)(1) requires the employer to give employees who work with hazardous chemicals an opportunity to receive medical attention in three circumstances:

  • The employee develops signs or symptoms associated with a hazardous chemical the employee may have been exposed to in the laboratory.
  • Monitoring shows exposure above the action level, or the exposure limit where there is no action level, for a regulated substance with monitoring and medical surveillance requirements. Medical surveillance is then established as that standard prescribes.
  • A spill, leak, explosion or other event results in the likelihood of a hazardous exposure. The affected employee must be offered a medical consultation to determine whether an examination is needed.

Examinations and consultations are performed by or under the direct supervision of a licensed physician, at no cost to the employee, without loss of pay and at a reasonable time and place, subsection (g)(2). The written opinion the employer obtains under subsection (g)(4) may not reveal findings unrelated to occupational exposure. Section 5191(j) requires monitoring and medical records to be kept under Section 3204. Section 3204(d)(1) sets at least 30 years for exposure records and at least the duration of employment plus 30 years for medical records, with listed exceptions.

Particularly Hazardous Substances and the Annual Review

Section 5191(e)(3)(H) names three groups that need additional protection: select carcinogens, reproductive toxins and substances with a high degree of acute toxicity. The plan must give specific consideration to four provisions and include them where appropriate: a designated area, containment devices such as fume hoods or glove boxes, procedures for safe removal of contaminated waste, and decontamination procedures. A designated area, as defined in subsection (b), may be the entire laboratory, an area of it or a device such as a laboratory hood.

Section 5191(e)(4) requires the employer to review and evaluate the effectiveness of the plan at least annually and update it as necessary. The subsection does not prescribe a format. I use a dated review page that records who did the review, what was checked and what changed.

What to Do This Week

  • Find the date of the last documented plan review and compare it to the annual interval in Section 5191(e)(4).
  • Confirm the named Chemical Hygiene Officer is a current employee.
  • Compare the plan to the eight elements in Section 5191(e)(3)(A) through (H) and mark any that are missing or generic.
  • Screen the chemical inventory for select carcinogens, reproductive toxins and substances with high acute toxicity, and confirm the plan addresses them.
  • Check each fume hood for a working airflow monitor, a current airflow demonstration and a face velocity record that meets Section 5154.1(c).
  • Identify any work in the laboratory that is production or simulates production.

If you want a Chemical Hygiene Plan reviewed against Section 5191, or exposure monitoring for laboratory operations, see my industrial hygiene services or call (626) 546-9384.

Need help with a Cal/OSHA matter?

McNeil Safety Consulting provides Cal/OSHA citation defense, industrial hygiene, safety plan writing, and expert witness services throughout California. Call (626) 546-9384 or request a consultation.