Local Exhaust Ventilation Testing and Spray Booth Air Velocity Under Title 8 Sections 5143 and 5153

By Michael Karl McNeil, REP, RIH, EPP, QSD

A local exhaust system is usually installed, balanced once and then left alone until someone complains about odor or dust. When I ask for the last ventilation test record, the common answer is that the fan is running. Title 8, Section 5143, General Requirements of Mechanical Ventilation Systems, sets design and operating requirements for exhaust systems, a testing interval and a record retention period. Title 8, Section 5153 adds requirements for spray coating operations, including minimum air velocities into spray booths. This article covers both.

What Section 5143 Requires of the System

Section 5143(a) requires that the construction, installation, inspection, testing and maintenance of exhaust systems conform to Article 107 of the General Industry Safety Orders. It names ANSI Z9.2-1971 and NFPA 91-1973 as sources of additional guidance. Section 5140 defines local exhaust ventilation as a mechanical ventilation system with a hood located at or near the point of release.

The design requirements are:

  • Capture and conveyance. The system must be designed, constructed, maintained and operated to prevent harmful exposure by maintaining a volume and velocity of exhaust air sufficient to gather dusts, fumes, mists, vapors or gases and convey them to suitable points of safe disposal, Section 5143(a)(1).
  • Structural integrity. Exhaust ducts, inlet ducts and fan plenums must be designed, constructed and supported to prevent collapse of the ducts or failure of the supporting system, Section 5143(a)(2).
  • Clean-out access. Ducts conveying dusts, fumes and mists need inspection or clean-out doors at intervals not exceeding 12 feet of horizontal run for ducts up to 12 inches in diameter. The distance may be greater for larger ducts. The fan needs a clean-out door for servicing and, where necessary, a drain, Section 5143(a)(3).
  • Incompatible streams. Two or more operations may not be connected to the same exhaust system where the combination of substances removed may create a fire, explosion or chemical reaction hazard in the duct system, Section 5143(a)(4).

Section 5140 defines “harmful exposure” as exposure to dusts, fumes, mists, vapors or gases in excess of a permissible limit in Section 5155, or of a nature by inhalation that results in, or has a probability of resulting in, injury, illness, disease, impairment or loss of function. Section 5141(a) requires harmful exposures to be prevented by engineering controls whenever feasible.

The Annual Test and the Five-Year Record

Section 5143(a)(5) requires that the ventilation rate of every mechanical ventilation system used to prevent harmful exposure be tested after initial installation, after alterations or maintenance, and at least annually. The test is by pitot traverse of the exhaust duct or equivalent measurements. Section 5140 defines a pitot traverse as measurement of air velocity in a duct with a pitot tube at several points to obtain an accurate average. Records of these tests must be retained for at least five years.

The subsection does not list what the record must contain. My test records identify the system and the operation it serves, the date, the method and instrument, the traverse location, the measured velocity and calculated airflow, the design or baseline value used for comparison, and who performed the test.

The retest after maintenance is the one I most often find missing. The text states no exception for minor work, so I schedule a retest after fan, duct, hood or collector work.

Operation and Discharge

Section 5143(b) requires the exhaust system to be in operation continually during all operations for which it is designed. It must keep running for some time after those operations stop, the length depending on the circumstances and the effectiveness of the system.

Under Section 5143(c)(1), collected contaminants and the air outlet from every dust separator or collector must discharge to the outside atmosphere in a manner that will not cause a harmful exposure in any accessible workplace. Collecting systems that return air to work areas may be used if the contaminants that accumulate in the work area do not result in harmful exposure to employees. Section 5143(c)(2) requires air exhausted from blast-cleaning, grinding, buffing and polishing equipment, and from all other equipment requiring exhaust of dust or particulate, to be discharged through dust-collecting equipment.

Makeup Air

Section 5143(d) requires a supply of clean, fresh air, free of contamination from adjacent industrial exhaust systems, chimneys, stacks or vents. Four numbered requirements follow:

  • The outside air supply must enter the workroom in a manner that will not reduce the effectiveness of any local exhaust system, Section 5143(d)(1).
  • Seams and joints must be sealed if negative pressure exists within inlet ductwork and harmful quantities of gases, fumes or mists could infiltrate from the areas the ductwork passes through, Section 5143(d)(2).
  • Where the air supply is filtered, the filters must be replaced or cleaned regularly to prevent significant reductions in airflow. A pressure gauge must show the pressure drop across the filters and be marked at the pressure drop at which they need cleaning or replacement, Section 5143(d)(3).
  • Where makeup air is heated by combustion other than gas, the products of combustion may not be mixed with the makeup air. Gas heating that mixes combustion products into the makeup air must meet three conditions, including a limit of 2000 ppm of total combustible gas in the mixture on flame failure, Section 5143(d)(4).

In the field, a building short on makeup air shows it with doors that are hard to open, drafts at dock doors, and hoods that test below baseline with a clean filter and a sound fan.

Spray Coating Operations Under Section 5153

Section 5153 is titled Ventilation and Personal Protective Equipment Requirements for Spray Coating Operations. Subsection (a) requires spray coating operations, whenever practicable, to be confined to properly designed, constructed and adequately ventilated spray booths or spray rooms that meet both Section 5153 and Article 137. The operating requirements are:

  • Ventilation during and after spraying. Mechanical ventilation must run at all times while spraying is conducted and for a sufficient time afterward to exhaust flammable vapors from drying coated articles and finishing material residue, Section 5153(b)(1).
  • Unattended automatic spray. When spray is applied automatically without an attendant constantly on duty, the controls must be arranged so that spray cannot be applied unless the exhaust fans are operating, Section 5153(b)(2).
  • No recirculation. Air exhausted from spray operations may not be recirculated, and no means of heating makeup air may be located in a spray booth, Section 5153(c).
  • Flammable vapor dilution. Ventilation must be sufficient to dilute flammable vapors to less than 20 percent of their lower explosive limit, Section 5153(d).
  • Downdraft booths. Where a downdraft booth has doors, they must be closed when spray painting, Section 5153(f).
  • Respirators. A spray booth operator positioned downstream from the object being sprayed is required to wear a respirator, and respirator use must conform to Section 5144, Section 5153(g).

Spray Booth Air Velocity in Table V-6

Section 5153(e) requires the velocity of air into all openings of a spray booth to be not less than the values in Table V-6, Minimum Maintained Velocities Into Spray Booths. The table covers objects completely inside the booth and gives an average and a minimum velocity in feet per minute (fpm). A note to the table defines a large booth as a walk-in size booth.

  • Electrostatic and automatic airless operation, crossdraft up to 50 fpm: large booth, 60 average and 60 minimum; small booth, 100 average and 75 minimum.
  • Air-operated guns, manual or automatic, crossdraft up to 50 fpm: large booth, 100 average and 75 minimum; small booth, 150 average and 125 minimum.
  • Air-operated guns, manual or automatic, crossdraft from 50 to 100 fpm: large booth, 150 average and 125 minimum; small booth, 200 average and 150 minimum.

A booth survey should record readings across the full opening so that both the average and the lowest point can be compared to the table. Where the booth exhaust is relied on to prevent harmful exposure, the annual test and five-year record in Section 5143(a)(5) apply to it as well.

What to Do This Week

  • List every exhaust system used to control an air contaminant and the operation it serves.
  • Find the last ventilation rate test for each one. Check that it is less than a year old and that a test followed the last alteration or maintenance.
  • Confirm that test records go back five years and can be produced on request.
  • Check each makeup air filter gauge for a mark showing the pressure drop at which filters are changed.
  • Measure air velocity at each spray booth and compare the average and the lowest reading to Table V-6 for the spray method and booth size.
  • Verify that automatic spray equipment without a constant attendant cannot spray unless the exhaust fans are running.
  • Look for duct runs carrying dust, fume or mist without clean-out doors.

If you need exhaust systems or spray booths tested and documented against Sections 5143 and 5153, see my industrial hygiene services or call (626) 546-9384.

Need help with a Cal/OSHA matter?

McNeil Safety Consulting provides Cal/OSHA citation defense, industrial hygiene, safety plan writing, and expert witness services throughout California. Call (626) 546-9384 or request a consultation.