An administrative law judge’s decision on a Cal/OSHA appeal is not the last word, but the next step has a short clock and a narrow door. A party who disagrees with the decision can petition the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board for reconsideration. That petition is the only route to the Board itself, and it is also the gate to any later court review. The rules are in Labor Code sections 6614 through 6627 and in the Board’s own procedural rules, Article 5 of Title 8, sections 389 through 394. This post walks through the deadline, the five permitted grounds, what the Board can do with the petition, and the writ of mandate that follows. It is a practical overview, not legal advice.
The 30-Day Deadline
Labor Code section 6614(a) allows any party aggrieved directly or indirectly by a final order or decision of the Appeals Board or a hearing officer to petition for reconsideration within 30 days after service of that order or decision. In the statute, “hearing officer” is the decision-maker at the hearing level; in current practice that is the administrative law judge. The Board’s rule at 8 CCR section 390(a) repeats the 30 days from service and requires that the petition be filed with the Appeals Board.
Two other timing rules matter:
- Under 8 CCR section 391.1(a), a petition that complies with the rules is deemed filed on the date shown on its proof of service. Without a proof of service, it is deemed filed on the date it is received at the Appeals Board’s office.
- Under section 391.1(b), if the petition is not verified or lacks a proof of service, the Board sends a letter noting the omission, and the petitioner has five days from service of that letter to cure it. If the defect is not cured, section 391.1(c) says the petition is dismissed.
Section 390.3(a) states the consequence of missing the deadline. If no petition is filed within 30 days and the Board does not order reconsideration on its own motion, the order or decision becomes a final order of the Appeals Board and is not subject to review by any court or agency. The deadlines for the original appeal of a citation are a separate set of rules, covered in Cal/OSHA citation appeal deadlines.
The Five Grounds, and Only Five
Labor Code section 6617 lists the grounds for reconsideration and says no others are allowed. A petition may be based on one or more of these:
- The Board or hearing officer acted without or in excess of its powers.
- The order or decision was procured by fraud.
- The evidence does not justify the findings of fact.
- The petitioner has discovered new evidence, material to it, that could not with reasonable diligence have been discovered and produced at the hearing.
- The findings of fact do not support the order or decision.
The Board’s rule at 8 CCR section 390.1(a) mirrors the same list. In the petitions I see, the third and fifth grounds do most of the work: the evidence in the hearing record did not support a finding, or the findings as written do not support the classification, penalty, or affirmance the judge reached. A petition that simply disagrees with the outcome is weak from the start.
What the Petition Must Contain
Labor Code section 6616 requires the petition to set forth specifically and in full detail the grounds on which the petitioner considers the order or decision unjust or unlawful, and every issue to be considered by the Board. It must be verified upon oath in the manner required for verified pleadings in courts of record, and it must contain a general statement of any evidence or other matters relied on.
The Board’s rule at 8 CCR section 391 adds two consequences that are easy to overlook:
- Any objection or issue not raised in the petition is deemed waived. Labor Code section 6618 says the same thing in statutory form: the petitioner is deemed to have finally waived all objections, irregularities, and illegalities not set forth in the petition.
- A petition will be denied if it contains no more than allegations of the statutory grounds, without specific references to the record and the principles of law involved.
The practical lesson is that the petition has to be built from the hearing record. Cite the exhibits and testimony, explain which finding is unsupported and why, and identify the legal principle.
Service matters too. Under Labor Code section 6619, the petition must be served forthwith on all parties, and any party may file an answer within 30 days of service. 8 CCR section 392 requires service and proof of service in the manner set out in sections 355.3 and 355.4.
Does Filing Stop the Decision?
Only partly, and only for a short time. Labor Code section 6625(a)(1) provides that filing a petition for reconsideration suspends the order or decision for 10 days as to the parties to the petition, unless the Board orders otherwise. Beyond that, section 6625(a)(2) and 8 CCR section 390.9 give the Board discretion to stay, suspend, or postpone the order or decision while reconsideration is pending.
Abatement is treated differently. Under section 6625(b), for a final order involving a citation classified as serious, repeat serious, or willful serious, filing or pendency of the petition does not stay the duty to abate the affirmed hazards. The employer can seek a stay only by filing a written, verified petition with supporting declarations within 10 days after issuance of the order or decision, and must show by a preponderance of the evidence that suspending abatement will not adversely affect employee health and safety. Plan to keep abating.
What the Board Reviews and What It Can Do
Under Labor Code section 6620 and 8 CCR section 390.1(b), when a petition is filed the Board may affirm, rescind, alter, or amend the decision on the existing record, with or without further proceedings, or grant reconsideration and direct that additional evidence be taken. The rule lets the Board request oral argument, briefs, and amicus curiae briefs, and the taking of additional evidence is governed by sections 393 and 394. Section 6621 allows the Board to decide on the existing record without further testimony when no sufficient reason for more testimony exists.
Decisions granting or denying reconsideration, and decisions after reconsideration, must be made by the Board, not a hearing officer. Labor Code section 6623 requires them to be in writing, signed by a majority of the assigned members, to state the evidence relied on, and to specify in detail the reasons for the decision. The Board may also reconsider on its own motion within 30 days of the filing of the decision, under section 6614(b) and 8 CCR section 390.2(a).
Timing on the Board’s side is set by Labor Code section 6624. A petition is deemed denied unless the Board acts on it within 45 days from the date of filing, which the Board may extend by up to 15 days for good cause. The Board’s rule at 8 CCR section 390.3(b) states the 45 days as running from service of the petition. Track both dates and treat the earlier one as the trigger for your next step.
After Reconsideration: The Writ of Mandate
Court review comes only after reconsideration. Labor Code section 6615 says no cause of action arising from a final order or decision accrues in any court unless the Board has taken the matter on its own motion or the person has petitioned for reconsideration and the petition has been granted or denied. Skipping reconsideration forfeits the court route.
Once reconsideration is complete, section 6627 allows any person affected by the Board’s order or decision to apply to the superior court of the county in which the applicant resides for a writ of mandate, to inquire into and determine the lawfulness of the original order or decision or of the order or decision after reconsideration. The deadline is 30 days: from the denial if reconsideration was denied, or from the filing of the order or decision following reconsideration if it was granted. The writ is a court proceeding with its own procedural rules, and it is the point at which an employer should have an attorney handling the case.
What to Do This Week
- If you have an ALJ decision, find the service date and calendar day 30 for the petition.
- Order the hearing record and identify each finding you dispute, tied to one of the five grounds in section 6617.
- If a serious citation was affirmed, confirm abatement is on track, and decide within 10 days whether to seek a stay under section 6625(b).
- Calendar the Board’s 45-day action window and the 30-day writ deadline that follows it.
If you need help reviewing an ALJ decision, the hearing record, or the technical basis of a citation, see Cal/OSHA violation defense, request a consultation, or call (626) 546-9384.