Most Cal/OSHA enforcement moves on a timeline of weeks and months: an inspection, a citation, an appeal window, a hearing. An Order Prohibiting Use does not. It is issued on the spot, it stops work in a defined area or on a defined piece of equipment immediately, and it stays in place until the Division is satisfied the hazard is gone. In the field it is often called a “red tag.” The authority comes from three short sections of the Labor Code: §6325, which creates the order; §6326, which makes violating it a crime; and §6327, which gives the employer a fast hearing. This post covers what each one says, how the order is posted and lifted, and how to respond if one lands on your site.
The Legal Standard: Imminent Hazard
Labor Code §6325(a) authorizes the Division to prohibit entry into, or use of, a place of employment or a machine, device, apparatus or equipment, or any part of one, when it finds that the place or equipment is in a dangerous condition, is not properly guarded, or is dangerously placed so as to constitute an “imminent hazard to employees.”
Three elements are worth separating:
- The object. The order attaches to a place or a specific piece of equipment, not to the employer generally.
- The condition. Dangerous condition, inadequate guarding, or dangerous placement.
- The threshold. The hazard must be imminent. A serious but non-imminent condition is handled through the ordinary citation process.
The statute does not define “imminent.” The Division’s internal Policy and Procedures Manual, in P&P C-8, “Order Prohibiting Use,” describes the test its staff apply: a hazard that could reasonably be expected to cause death or serious physical harm immediately, or before it can be abated through normal enforcement procedures. The same document directs staff to warn the employer and affected employees, encourage immediate correction, and issue the order only if the employer cannot or does not eliminate the hazard immediately. The copy I reviewed shows a last revision date of November 14, 2000, so treat it as a description of the Division’s stated practice rather than a binding rule. It is still the best explanation of how an inspector is expected to reach the decision.
Scope Is Limited to the Immediate Area
Section 6325(a) contains an important limit. The Division shall not prohibit entry into or use of a place of employment outside the “immediate area in which the imminent hazard exists.” An order on one excavation is not an order shutting down the project. An order on one press is not an order closing the plant.
When I review an order after the fact, this is one of the first things I check. Is the area or equipment described precisely enough that a foreman knows exactly what is off-limits? Does the tagged area match the hazard, or does it sweep in work that has nothing to do with it? Ambiguity here causes two problems: crews stop work they could lawfully continue, or they continue work the order actually covers.
Posting the Order
Under §6325(a), when the Division prohibits entry or use, a conspicuous notice is attached to the place or equipment. The statute says the notice “shall not be removed except by an authorized representative of the division.”
P&P C-8 describes the mechanics as the Division states them. The order itself is a written form (Form 8) recording the location, the standard or code section involved, a description of each hazard, the issuing officer, the date and time, and the number of tags attached. The tag, which the manual describes as a yellow tag (Form S-172), is secured to the area or equipment and identifies what is prohibited. The order and a declaration of service are served on the employer. So despite the “red tag” nickname, the Division’s own manual describes the tag as yellow.
If the inspection also produces citations, a separate posting rule applies. Under 8 CCR §332.4, citations, special orders and orders to take special action must be posted at or near the site of the violation so employees working nearby can easily read them, for three working days or until the unsafe condition is abated, whichever is longer. Section 332.4 does not itself address Orders Prohibiting Use; I found no Title 8 section that does, so the Labor Code is the controlling text for the order.
Working Under the Order and Getting the Tag Removed
Section 6325(a) allows entry while the order is in effect only with the knowledge and permission of the Division, and only “for the sole purpose of eliminating the dangerous conditions.” Abatement work is permitted. Production work is not.
The notice comes off only when the place or equipment “is made safe and the required safeguards or safety appliances or devices are provided,” and only an authorized Division representative may remove it. Fixing the problem does not by itself lift the order. The employer has to get the Division back to verify the correction and remove the tag.
P&P C-8 sets no fixed timeline for that follow-up. It states that the order remains in effect until the Division determines the hazard has been eliminated. It also describes a limited exception in remote locations, where the District Manager may authorize the employer or another person to remove the tag and return it to the district office. Absent that kind of express authorization, nobody on the employer’s side should touch the tag.
In practice, the fastest path to removal is documentation. Photograph the corrected condition, keep the work orders or purchase records for the guard or device installed, note who did the work, and call the district office the moment the work is done.
Criminal Exposure Under §6326
Labor Code §6326 makes it a misdemeanor for any person, after the notice is attached, to enter the place, or use or operate the machine, device, apparatus or equipment, before it is made safe and the required safeguards are provided. The same section covers anyone who defaces, destroys or removes the notice “without the authority of the division.” The penalty stated in the section is a fine of up to one thousand dollars ($1,000), up to one year in county jail, or both.
Note the words “any person.” The exposure is not limited to the company. A supervisor who sends a crew back into a tagged trench, or an employee who pulls a tag to finish a job, is personally within the statute. P&P C-8 directs staff who find a removed tag or work in violation of an order to notify the District Manager, who informs the Regional Manager and the Bureau of Investigations, and it calls for a reinspection.
Contesting the Order: The 24-Hour Hearing
Labor Code §6327 provides that once an authorized representative has prohibited entry or use under §6325, the employer may contest the order and “shall be granted, upon request, a hearing by the division to review the validity of the representative’s order.” The hearing “shall be held within 24 hours following the employer’s request.”
This is not an appeal to the Occupational Safety and Health Appeals Board. It is a Division hearing, and it moves very fast. P&P C-8 describes how the Division states it runs it:
- The employer is told of the right to request a hearing when the order is issued.
- The hearing is held at the district office, with the District Manager or a designee as hearing officer, and is recorded.
- The employer notifies employees of the date, time and place and provides proof of notice; employees or their representatives may attend.
- The Division presents eyewitness and photographic evidence, and both sides may question witnesses.
- The hearing officer decides validity on the record and tells the employer the decision immediately after the hearing.
Twenty-four hours is not much time to assemble photographs, measurements, manufacturer documentation and witnesses. Decide quickly whether the better route is a hearing or immediate abatement. Often abatement is faster. But where the order rests on a factual error, or covers far more than the immediate area, a hearing may be worth it. Any citations from the same inspection follow the separate appeal process and deadlines that apply to citations.
What to Do This Week
- Brief supervisors that a Division tag may only be removed by the Division and that §6326 reaches individuals, not just the company.
- Add an order-prohibiting-use response step to your site emergency or inspection procedure: who calls whom, who photographs what, who requests a §6327 hearing.
- Walk your highest-risk areas (excavations, unguarded machinery, elevated work) and correct anything an inspector could view as an imminent hazard.
- Keep abatement records organized so you can show correction the same day.
If your site has received an Order Prohibiting Use, or citations from the same inspection, see my OSHA violation defense services and the guide to Cal/OSHA citations. A pre-inspection safety audit is the best way to find imminent-hazard conditions first. To request a consultation, call (626) 546-9384.