When I review an electrical incident on a system of 600 volts or less, I ask who was allowed to open the enclosure, who decided the work would be done energized, and whether the disconnect was locked and tagged. California answers each one in Article 3 of the Low-Voltage Electrical Safety Orders, Title 8, Sections 2320.1 through 2320.9. This article covers what those sections say about qualified persons, energized work, lockout, tags and re-energizing.
Scope and the Qualified Person Rule
The Low-Voltage Electrical Safety Orders apply to electrical installations and equipment operating on systems of 600 volts, nominal, or less, and to all work performed directly on or in proximity to them, in all places of employment in California (Section 2305.2(a)).
Section 2320.1(a) says only qualified persons shall work on electrical equipment or systems. Subsection (b) says only qualified persons shall be permitted to perform any function in proximity to energized overhead conductors, unless means to prevent accidental contact have been provided in accordance with Articles 3 and 4 of the orders.
Section 2300 defines a qualified person as a person, designated by the employer, who has received training in and has demonstrated skills and knowledge in the construction and operation of electric equipment and installations and the hazards involved. An authorized person is a qualified person delegated to perform specific duties under the conditions existing. The lockout and re-energizing duties below fall on an authorized person.
Section 2300 prescribes no form for the designation, the training or the demonstration of skills. Where I see employers fall short is the maintenance mechanic who has always handled the electrical work, with nothing showing who designated him or what his training covered. I recommend a written designation by name that lists the equipment and tasks it covers.
When Energized Work Is Allowed
Section 2320.3 sets the default. All electrical equipment and systems are treated as energized, as required by Section 2320.2, until tested or otherwise proven to be de-energized. Under Section 2320.2(a), work shall not be performed on exposed energized parts of equipment or systems until these conditions are met:
- Responsible supervision has determined that the work is to be performed while the equipment or systems are energized (subsection (a)(1)).
- Involved personnel have received instructions on the work techniques and hazards involved in working on energized equipment ((a)(2)).
- Suitable personal protective equipment and safeguards (approved insulated gloves or insulated tools) are provided and used ((a)(3)). Rubber insulating gloves must meet ASTM D120-09 and be maintained under ASTM F496-08. Insulated tools must meet ASTM F 1505-01.
- Approved insulated gloves are worn for voltages in excess of 250 volts to ground ((a)(4)).
- Suitable barriers or approved insulating material are provided and used to prevent accidental contact with energized parts ((a)(5)).
- Suitable eye protection has been provided and is used ((a)(6)).
- Where required for personnel protection, suitable barricades, tags or signs are in place ((a)(7)).
- Each employee exposed to flames or electric arcs wears apparel that does not increase the extent of injury. Acetate, nylon, polyester and rayon, alone or in blends, are prohibited unless the employer can demonstrate that the fabric has been treated with flame retardant ((a)(8)).
The section does not call for a written permit for the first condition. I recommend one, naming who made the determination and for which task.
There is one exception to (a)(3). Insulating gloves, insulated tools and other protective measures are not required on exposed parts energized at less than 50 volts, provided a qualified person has made a conclusive determination before the start of work that there will be no employee exposure to electrical shock, electrical burns, explosion or hazards due to electric arcs. The note to (a)(3)(A) states that ASTM F496-08 limits electrical retests to 6 months for insulating gloves and 12 months for insulating sleeves.
Subsection (b) sets the order for making connections: attach the wire to the de-energized part first, and remove the source end first when disconnecting. Subsection (c) makes an authorized person responsible, after the work, for removing temporary protective equipment and reinstalling all permanent barriers or covers. Subsection (d) sets the minimum approach distance rule for conductive objects.
De-Energizing: Notification, Lockout, Tagging and Stored Energy
Under Section 2320.4(a), an authorized person is responsible for four steps before work on de-energized equipment or systems, unless the equipment is physically removed from the wiring system:
- Notify. Notifying all involved personnel ((a)(1)).
- Lock. Locking the disconnecting means in the “open” position with lockable devices such as padlocks or combination locks, by disconnecting the conductors, or by other positive methods or procedures that effectively prevent unexpected or inadvertent energizing of the designated circuit, equipment or appliance ((a)(2)).
- Tag. Tagging the disconnecting means with suitable accident prevention tags conforming to Section 2320.6 and General Industry Safety Orders Section 3314(e) ((a)(3)).
- Control stored energy. Effectively blocking the operation or dissipating the energy of all stored energy devices which present a hazard, such as capacitors or pneumatic, spring-loaded and like mechanisms ((a)(4)).
Locking is not required where tagging procedures under (a)(3) are used and the disconnecting means is accessible only to personnel instructed in those tagging procedures. A tag on a breaker that production employees or other trades can reach does not fit the exception unless every one of them has been instructed in the tagging procedure.
After the disconnect is locked, Section 2320.3 still treats the equipment as energized until it is tested or otherwise proven de-energized. I look for a voltage test at the point of work, using a meter checked on a known live source.
Accident Prevention Tags
Section 2320.6(a) requires suitable accident prevention tags to control a specific hazard. Each tag must provide at least:
- The reason for placing the tag.
- The name of the person placing the tag and how that person may be contacted.
- The date the tag was placed.
Section 3314(e), which Section 2320.4(a)(3) pulls in, covers the hardware. The employer provides the tags, padlocks and seals, and they must be readily securable to the controls. Tagout device attachment means must be non-reusable, attachable by hand, self-locking and non-releasable, with a minimum unlocking strength of no less than 50 pounds. A blank “Do Not Operate” tag tied on with string does not match the text of either section.
Re-Energizing
Section 2320.5(a) assigns two duties to an authorized person before equipment or systems are energized again: determining that all persons are clear from hazards which might result from energizing, and removing locking devices and tags. Under (a)(2)(A), locking devices and tags may be removed only by the employee who placed them, upon completion of the work and after the protective guards and/or safety interlock systems are installed.
The exception covers the employee who has left the premises or is otherwise unavailable. The employer may then authorize other persons to remove the devices and tags in accordance with a procedure determined by the employer. If your procedure is not written down, write it before the first time someone goes home with the key.
Other Precautions in Sections 2320.7 Through 2320.9
Section 2320.8 covers fall protection more than 4 feet above the ground on poles, towers or similar structures. The other two sections reach ordinary plant and building work:
- Section 2320.7(a): suitable temporary barriers or barricades when access to opened enclosures containing exposed energized equipment is not under the control of an authorized person.
- Section 2320.7(b) and (c): no conductive measuring tapes or ropes on or near exposed energized conductors or parts, and no conductive fish tapes in raceways entering enclosures with exposed energized parts unless those parts are isolated by suitable barriers.
- Section 2320.7(d): employees within reaching distance of exposed energized parts remove exposed conductive articles such as keychains, rings and wrist watches, unless the articles do not increase the hazard.
- Section 2320.9: no electrical power source, permanent or temporary, may be connected to a premises wiring system unless positive means prevent the transmission of electricity beyond that system or beyond any intentionally segregated parts of it. The exception is an interconnection authorized by the servicing utility. Read this section before a portable generator is tied into a building.
What to Do This Week
- List every employee who works on electrical equipment and confirm each is designated as a qualified person, with training and demonstrated skills you can show (Sections 2300 and 2320.1(a)).
- Identify the tasks performed energized and confirm responsible supervision made that determination for each (Section 2320.2(a)(1)).
- Pull the insulating gloves and compare the test dates to the ASTM F496-08 intervals noted in Section 2320.2(a)(3)(A).
- Walk to three disconnects and confirm each can be locked open (Section 2320.4(a)(2)).
- Read one of your tags against Section 2320.6 for reason, name, contact and date, and check its attachment against Section 3314(e).
- Find your procedure for removing an absent employee’s lock and tag (Section 2320.5(a)(2)(A), Exception).
For an outside review of your electrical work practices and lockout steps against these sections, see my safety audit service or call (626) 546-9384.