Air sampling results, biological monitoring results, safety data sheets, medical questionnaires, and examination results all fall under one access and retention rule in California: Title 8, Section 3204. The section sets how long these records are kept, who can ask for them, how fast the employer has to produce them, what employees must be told, and what happens to the records when a business closes.
Who Is Covered and What Counts as a Record
Section 3204(b) applies to each employer who makes, maintains, contracts for, or has access to employee exposure or medical records, or analyses of them, for employees exposed to toxic substances or harmful physical agents. It applies whether or not the records relate to a specific standard, and whether they are kept in-house or by a contractor such as a clinic or laboratory. Section 3204(c)(13) defines those agents broadly: chemical substances, biological agents, and physical stresses such as noise, heat, vibration, and radiation qualify if, among other criteria, they are regulated by California or federal law due to a hazard to health.
Employee Exposure Records
Under Section 3204(c)(5), an exposure record is a record containing any of the following:
- Environmental (workplace) monitoring or measuring, including personal, area, grab, wipe, or other sampling, with the related collection and analytical methods, calculations, and background data.
- Biological monitoring results that directly assess absorption of a substance or agent by body systems, such as the level of a chemical in blood, urine, or breath. Results that assess biological effect, or alcohol or drug use, are excluded.
- Safety data sheets indicating that the material may pose a hazard to human health.
- In the absence of the above, a chemical inventory or other record that reveals the identity of the substance or agent and where and when it was used.
Employee Medical Records
Section 3204(c)(6) defines a medical record as a record concerning the health status of an employee that is made or maintained by a physician, nurse, other health care personnel, or technician. It includes medical and employment questionnaires or histories, results of medical examinations and laboratory tests, medical opinions, diagnoses, progress notes and recommendations, first-aid records, descriptions of treatments and prescriptions, and employee medical complaints. Section 3204(c)(6)(B) excludes four categories, among them routinely discarded physical specimens and separately maintained voluntary employee assistance program records.
Retention Periods
Section 3204(d)(1) sets these periods unless a specific occupational safety and health regulation provides a different one:
- Medical records: at least the duration of employment plus 30 years, Section 3204(d)(1)(A). Exceptions cover separately maintained health insurance claims records, certain on-site first aid records of minor injuries, and records of employees who worked less than one year if given to the employee at termination.
- Exposure records: at least 30 years, Section 3204(d)(1)(B). Background data such as laboratory reports and worksheets need only be kept one year, as long as the sampling results, the sampling plan, a description of the analytical and mathematical methods, and a summary of other relevant background data are kept for 30 years.
- Safety data sheets: retained as necessary to comply with Title 8, Section 5194. Where a sheet is destroyed, a record of the identity of the substance, where it was used, and when it was used is kept for at least 30 years.
- Analyses using exposure or medical records: at least 30 years, Section 3204(d)(1)(C).
Section 3204(d)(2) does not mandate a format, as long as the information is preserved and retrievable, except that chest X-ray films are preserved in their original state.
Who May Request Access and How Fast
An employee under Section 3204(c)(4) is a current employee, a former employee, or an employee being assigned or transferred to work where there will be exposure. A designated representative is any individual or organization the employee authorizes in writing. A recognized or certified collective bargaining agent is automatically a designated representative for exposure records and analyses, but needs the employee’s written consent for medical records.
Under Section 3204(e)(1)(A), access is provided in a reasonable time, place, and manner, and in no event later than 15 days after the request. An employer that needs more time asks the Chief of the Division for an extension before the 15 days run, after notice to the requester, and the extension is granted on a finding of good cause. Other general rules in Section 3204(e)(1):
- The employer may ask the requester only for information needed to locate the records, such as dates and locations of work.
- The first copy is without cost: the employer provides a copy, makes copying equipment available, or loans the record for a reasonable time so a copy can be made.
- For additional copies of a record already provided, the employer may charge reasonable, non-discriminatory search and copying costs, but not overhead.
A designated representative seeking exposure records without the employee’s consent makes the request in writing and states the records sought and the occupational health need (Section 3204(e)(2)(A)2).
Employees have access to their own medical records. A designated representative needs specific written consent as defined in Section 3204(c)(12), which does not operate for more than one year. Appendix A to the section is a sample form. Section 3204(e)(2)(B)4 has one limit: where a physician representing the employer believes direct access to information about a specific diagnosis of a terminal illness or psychiatric condition could be detrimental to the employee’s health, the employer may deny the employee’s request for direct access to that information only, and must tell the employee that access will be provided only to a designated representative with specific written consent.
The Division has its own right of prompt access under Section 3204(e)(3). A written access order for personally identifiable medical information is posted for at least 15 working days.
Employee Information at Hire and Annually
Section 3204(g)(1) requires each employer, when an employee first enters employment and at least annually after that, to inform covered employees of three things: the existence, location, and availability of the records; the person responsible for maintaining and providing access to them; and each employee’s rights of access. Section 3204(g)(2) requires the employer to keep a copy of Section 3204 and its appendices and make copies readily available to employees on request. This is the item I most often find missing in a safety audit: the records exist, but employees have not been told and the annual notice is not documented.
Trade Secrets
Section 3204(f) lets an employer delete trade secret data that discloses manufacturing processes or the percentage of a chemical in a mixture, provided the requester is told of the deletion. The employer may also withhold a specific chemical identity if it supports the trade secret claim with evidence, discloses all other available information on the properties and effects of the substance, and tells the requester the identity is being withheld. Two limits apply. In a medical emergency, when a treating physician or nurse determines the identity is necessary for emergency or first-aid treatment, the employer discloses it immediately (Section 3204(f)(3)). In non-emergency situations, the identity is disclosed on a written request that describes the occupational health need, explains why the identity is essential, and is backed by a written confidentiality agreement (Section 3204(f)(4)). A denial must be in writing within 30 days of the request and include evidence supporting the trade secret claim, and the requester may refer it to the Division (Section 3204(f)(8) and (f)(9)).
Transfer of Records When a Business Closes
Under Section 3204(h), an employer that is ceasing to do business transfers all records subject to the section to the successor employer. If there is no successor, the employer notifies affected employees of their rights of access at least three months before the business ceases. In that situation, or whenever an employer intends to dispose of records required to be kept 30 years, the employer either transfers the records to the Director of NIOSH if a specific standard requires it, or notifies the Director of NIOSH in writing at least three months before disposal.
What to Do This Week
- List every place exposure and medical records are held: your own files, the occupational clinic, the laboratory, and any outside industrial hygiene reports.
- Check that contracts with clinics and laboratories provide for the retention periods in Section 3204(d) and for access within the 15-day limit in Section 3204(e)(1)(A).
- Name in writing the person responsible for maintaining the records and answering access requests.
- Verify that new-hire orientation and an annual notice cover the three items in Section 3204(g)(1), keep proof of both, and keep a copy of Section 3204 and its appendices available to employees.
- Before purging old safety data sheets, make sure a record remains of the substance identity, where it was used, and when.
- If a sale, merger, or closure is planned, add the Section 3204(h) transfer and notice steps to the transaction checklist.
I set up and review exposure and medical record systems for California employers. To have your records checked against Section 3204, see recordkeeping and medical surveillance or call (626) 546-9384.