Scaffold Safety in California: Title 8, Section 1637 and the Section 341 Permit

By Michael Karl McNeil, REP, RIH, EPP, QSD

Most scaffold problems I find on California jobsites are visible from the ground: a platform with a missing plank, an open end with no rail, a frame being climbed because nobody installed access, a scaffold well over 36 feet with no permit on file. This article walks through what Title 8, Section 1637 requires for every construction scaffold, what Title 8, Sections 1644 and 1646 add for metal and rolling scaffolds, and when Title 8, Section 341 requires a Cal/OSHA permit before the first frame goes up.

Design, Load Ratings and the Qualified Person

Section 1637(a) requires scaffolds for all work that cannot be done safely by employees standing on permanent or solid construction at least 20 inches wide, except where the work can be done safely from ladders. Section 1637(b)(2) then requires each scaffold to be designed and constructed to support, without failure, its own weight and 4 times the maximum intended working load. The maximum intended working load is set by duty class:

  • Light-duty: 25 pounds per square foot of work platform.
  • Medium-duty: 50 pounds per square foot.
  • Heavy-duty: 75 pounds per square foot.
  • Special-duty: more than 75 pounds per square foot, as determined by a qualified person or a civil engineer currently registered in California and experienced in scaffold design.
  • Engineered scaffolds: as determined by a California-registered civil engineer experienced in scaffold design.

Section 1637(b)(4) requires manufactured scaffolds to be used in accordance with the manufacturer’s recommendations. Section 1637(b)(5) requires a qualified person to determine the maximum intended working load for a scaffold that is neither manufactured nor engineered. Section 1637(b)(6) requires that load to be posted at a conspicuous location at each jobsite or provided to each supervisory employee, who must have it readily available at the jobsite.

Section 1637(k)(1) requires erection and dismantling to be performed under the supervision and direction of a qualified person. Where the orders require engineering design, Section 1637(k)(2) requires the engineering drawings to be available at the job site during erection or upon request by the Division. Section 1644(c)(7) requires drawings and specifications for frame scaffolds over 125 feet in height above the base plates to be designed by a civil engineer currently registered in California.

Planking and Platforms

Section 1637(f) and (g) hold the planking rules:

  • Size and grade. Solid sawn planking must be at least equivalent to 2-inch by 10-inch nominal lumber selected for scaffold grade plank, and before it goes into service it must be certified by, or bear the grade stamp of, a grading agency approved by the American Lumber Standards Committee (Section 1637(f)(1) and (f)(5)).
  • Span. For Douglas Fir and Southern Pine 2 x 10 nominal planks, the maximum permissible span is 10 feet at a 25 psf working load, 8 feet at 50 psf and 7 feet at 75 psf (Section 1637(f)(2)(A)).
  • Overhang. A plank may not overhang its support by more than 18 inches unless a guardrail or other barrier prevents access to the overhanging portion or the other end is securely anchored (Section 1637(g)).

On metal scaffolds, Section 1644(a)(7) requires planks of 2-inch by 10-inch or wider material that overlap the ledgers at each end by at least 6 inches. The platform must cover the entire space between scaffold uprights except for an open area under the back railing no more than 10 inches wide, and the inboard edge may be no more than 16 inches from the building or structure wall.

Guardrails and Toeboards

The trigger height for scaffold railings in the Construction Safety Orders is 7 1/2 feet. Section 1644(a)(6) requires securely attached railings on the open sides and ends of metal scaffold work platforms 7 1/2 feet or more above grade. The top rail must be not less than 42 inches nor more than 45 inches above the platform, with a midrail approximately halfway between the top rail and the platform. Section 1646(b)(1) applies the same requirement to tower and rolling scaffolds, and Title 8, Section 1640(b)(4) sets the equivalent for light-duty wooden pole scaffolds.

Title 8, Section 1621(b) requires toeboards on all open sides and ends of railed scaffolds at locations where persons are required to work or pass under the scaffold. A standard toeboard is at least 4 inches nominal in height.

Access, Ties and Rolling Scaffolds

Section 1637(n)(1) requires a safe and unobstructed means of access, such as a walkway, stair or ladder, to all scaffold platforms. Under Section 1637(n)(2)(A), manufactured hook-on and attachable ladders must be specifically designed for the type of scaffold and securely attached, with the bottom rung no more than 24 inches above the scaffold supporting level and rest platforms at intervals of 35 feet or less on a supported scaffold more than 35 feet high.

Section 1644(a)(5) requires metal scaffolds to be securely tied to the building or structure at intervals not exceeding 30 feet horizontally. Ties are required at the free ends when the platform height exceeds 3 times the least base dimension, across the rest of the first row when the platform height is 4 times the least base dimension, and at 26-foot vertical intervals above that. During dismantling, ties come out only as the work progresses downward unless other methods keep the scaffold from falling over (Section 1637(k)(4)).

For rolling scaffolds, Section 1646(a) requires the minimum base dimension of a free-standing tower or rolling scaffold to be at least 1/3 the height unless it is securely guyed or tied. Section 1646(c) requires wheels or casters to have an effective locking device and to be kept locked when workers are climbing or working on the scaffold.

Inspection and Daily Use

Section 1637(f)(6) requires all scaffold planks to be visually inspected for defects before use each day, and Section 1637(f)(7) requires defective or damaged planks to be removed from service. Section 1637(h) requires all scaffold lumber to be visually inspected for defects before and during use. Section 1644(a)(2) prohibits using metal scaffold equipment that is broken or deteriorated to the extent that its section is structurally weakened.

Uprights, braces and supports may not be removed unless members providing equivalent strength are substituted (Section 1637(l)). Work on or from scaffolds is prohibited during storms or high winds unless a qualified person has determined it is safe and the employees are protected by a personal fall arrest system or wind screens (Section 1637(u)). Where I see employers fall short is the trade that pulls a brace or midrail to pass material and never puts it back. I recommend a documented check of the whole scaffold by the qualified person at the start of each shift and after any alteration. Section 1637 does not prescribe that record.

The Section 341 Permit Trigger

Section 341(d)(5)(B) requires the employer to hold an Annual or a Project Permit for the erection and placement of scaffolding, vertical shoring or falsework intended to be more than 36 feet high when completed. The measure is the intended completed height, so the permit question is settled at planning. Under Section 341(b)(6), holding a permit means having a valid permit obtained prior to the start of work.

For dismantling, read two provisions together. Section 341(b)(10) lists scaffolding in its definition of “structure”, and Section 341(d)(3) requires permits for the demolition or dismantling of any building or structure more than 36 feet in height: a Project Permit for the Project Administrator and an Annual Permit for every other employer directly engaged in the work.

Section 341(c)(2)(B) requires an Annual Permit holder to notify the Division each time it begins permit-required activity at a new site, and Title 8, Section 341.1(h)(2)(B) sets that notice at least 24 hours before the activity. Section 341(e) exempts government bodies and public utilities under Public Utilities Commission jurisdiction.

What to Do This Week

  • List the intended completed height of every scaffold on the schedule. Anything planned above 36 feet needs an Annual or Project Permit in hand before erection starts.
  • If you work under an Annual Permit, confirm the Division district office was notified at least 24 hours before work began at each current site.
  • Name the qualified person supervising erection and dismantling on each job and keep the basis for that qualification on file.
  • Check that the maximum intended working load is posted at the jobsite or in each supervisor’s hands.
  • Walk every platform 7 1/2 feet or more above grade: top rail at 42 to 45 inches, midrail in place, toeboards wherever people work or pass below.
  • Check planks for grade stamps, 6-inch overlap at the ledgers and overhang of 18 inches or less, and pull any damaged plank from service.
  • Verify ladder, stair or walkway access to each platform and tie spacing against Section 1644(a)(5).

I review scaffold plans, permit readiness and jobsite conditions for contractors and owners as part of my construction safety services. Request a consultation through the site or call (626) 546-9384.

Need help with a Cal/OSHA matter?

McNeil Safety Consulting provides Cal/OSHA citation defense, industrial hygiene, safety plan writing, and expert witness services throughout California. Call (626) 546-9384 or request a consultation.